12 complete symptom paths42 guides and 60 questions in each1,460 Grade A articlesOne searchable, connected knowledge library140 official sourcesEvidence context with explicit limits
Guided evidence worksheet

Roof water paths: drainage versus hidden entry

Record the first visible change, the rain direction, the delay before wetting, and every roof detail uphill from the exit point.

Roof water paths: drainage versus hidden entryCompare a normal shingle-to-gutter route with water that crosses a failed flashing or underlayment detail and appears far from the entry point. Original explanatory diagram, not a site photograph.
Reasoning guardrail

Separate the routes before choosing a repair.

The ceiling mark is not necessarily directly below the roof defect.

Trigger
Rain direction, duration and wind pressure are more diagnostic than stain color.
Area
Attic
Provenance
Original explanatory diagram, not a site photograph.
1. Freeze the evidence

What happened first?

2. Competing hypotheses

Record evidence for and against each route.

1

Roof covering or flashing entry

Rain crosses a roof detail and travels along decking, underlay or framing before it appears indoors.

Evidence that raises fit
Evidence that lowers fit
Notes
2

Plumbing or condensate source above

A pipe, fixture, drain or condensate route wets the same ceiling area independently of weather.

Evidence that raises fit
Evidence that lowers fit
Notes
3

Stored water released after the event

Insulation or a concealed cavity temporarily stores water and releases it after the exterior event has ended.

Evidence that raises fit
Evidence that lowers fit
Notes
3. Decision points

Change one condition at a time.

1

Can the symptom be reproduced during dry weather by using plumbing or HVAC equipment above?

Yes: Move plumbing or condensate routes ahead of the roof pathway.

No: Keep weather-driven entry as the leading family and map wind direction and delay.

Observed answer and evidence
2

Does the first wet edge align with an uphill penetration, valley, sidewall or flashing transition?

Yes: Inspect that detail and the concealed downhill travel route.

No: Widen the search to deck seams, fastener lines and alternate sources above.

Observed answer and evidence
4. Smallest safe checks

Plan the next observation.

1

Map the rain event

Record wind direction, rain duration and the delay before the mark changes.

2

Trace uphill safely

Inspect accessible roof-side details above the exit point without walking an unsafe roof.

3

Compare plumbing timing

Rule out fixtures or pipes above the stain when the weather link is weak.

Safety boundary

Stop rather than create a better clue.

  • Do not walk a wet, steep or fragile roof.
  • Stop if water is near lights, wiring or energized equipment.
5. Current conclusion

What changed the ranking?